PILINHA: {__webCacheId=filmBasicInfo_pl_PL, __webCacheKey=173500}

Wyznania gejszy

Memoirs of a Geisha
7,6 188 872
oceny
7,6 10 1 188872
6,1 14
ocen krytyków
Wyznania gejszy
powrót do forum filmu Wyznania gejszy

nawet nie musialam szukac dluzej niz minute a znalazlam ten fragment tekstu 'Iwasaki was one of several geisha author Arthur Golden interviewed while researching his novel Memoirs of a Geisha. According to Iwasaki, she agreed to speak with Golden on the condition that her involvement would be kept confidential, but Golden revealed her identity by mentioning her name in the book’s acknowledgments as well as several national interviews. After Memoirs was published, Iwasaki received criticism and even death threats for violating the traditional geisha code of silence. Iwasaki felt betrayed by Golden’s use of information she considered confidential, as well as the way he twisted reality. She denounced Memoirs of a Geisha as being an inaccurate depiction of the life of a geisha. Iwasaki was particularly offended by the novel’s portrayal of geiko engaging in ritualized prostitution. For example, in the novel the main character Sayuri’s virginity (called mizuage in the novel) is auctioned off to the highest bidder. Iwasaki stated that not only did this never happen to her, but that no such custom ever existed in Gion.
Part of Iwasaki’s displeasure with Memoirs may have been because the character Sayuri seems obviously modeled on Iwasaki, with many of the book’s main characters and events having parallels in Iwasaki’s life. These people and experiences are often portrayed negatively in Memoirs, even when their real-life counterparts were positive for Iwasaki. Iwasaki later gave public interviews citing that many established geiko criticized her interview with Arthur Golden, causing a rupture with the geisha tradition of secrecy to the outside world. Furthermore, Iwasaki has mentioned that she had lost some friends and relationships due to the scandal of her being known due to the book, along with certain inconsistencies and fallacies about Gion which were mentioned in Memoirs of a Geisha.
Iwasaki sued Golden for breach of contract and defamation of character in 2001, which was settled out of court in 2003.'

takze yeah,, portret gejszy w tym filmie jest absolutnie niepoprawny, traktowanie gejszy jako japonskiej prostytutki to gowno co sprawia ze ten film (ktory powinien honorowac japonską kulture a miesza ją z blotem) jest rowniez gownem

ocenił(a) film na 8
glithch

Podaj mi fragment, w którym mowa, że gejsze to dziwki. Książki zapewne nie czytałeś... Golden w swoim piśmie jasno powiedział, że Gejsze to nie "kurtyzany"

Haylash

pff to powiedziane jest raczej tylko dla zasady
to nie jest temat do dyskusji a ja nie mam zamiaru cie edukowac wiec polecam poszukac o tym na necie
'' In the film version, Michelle Yeoh reads a long speech about how a geisha must be an artist, how she is more a companion or a comfort, and definitely not a prostitute. Yet the film posits that a geisha's ultimate goal is to find a wealthy patron who will support her, and a major portion of the running time is consumed by a contest to sell off the virginity of our 15-year-old heroine (Ziyi Zhang) to the highest bidder.

The great romantic dream of our heroine, which she has cultivated from the age of nine, is to get close to "The Chairman," a businessman. The fact that he has two geisha companions when she first meets him convinces the little girl that she too wants to become a geisha -- not for the possible honor of the achievement, but solely so that she can spend time with "The Chairman." The best spin I could put on this childish romantic yearning is "yucch!" I'm not against romances between people widely-separated in age, but that whole vibe ('I loved you when I was a child, and now that I'm an adult I want to marry you or at least spend time with you in an intimate way') made me uncomfortable.''

Pobierz aplikację Filmwebu!

Odkryj świat filmu w zasięgu Twojej ręki! Oglądaj, oceniaj i dziel się swoimi ulubionymi produkcjami z przyjaciółmi.
phones